Woman frowning while examining a dental night guard near her mouth, suggesting concerns about its fit or effects on teeth grinding.

Can a Night Guard Make Teeth Grinding Worse?

You started wearing a night guard to protect your teeth, but now you're waking up with a tighter jaw or more discomfort. Could your night guard actually be making your teeth grinding worse?

It's possible. Some research suggests certain guard materials may increase jaw-muscle activity in some people, although the evidence is limited. Poor fit can also contribute to discomfort.

This article explains how night guards affect teeth grinding, how different types compare, and what to do if yours causes problems.

Can a Night Guard Make Teeth Grinding Worse?

Night guards protect your teeth from bruxism, which includes grinding, gnashing, and clenching. According to the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research (NIDCR), bruxism can happen during sleep or while you're awake and may cause tooth damage and jaw discomfort.

However, protecting your teeth doesn't necessarily stop grinding. The Mayo Clinic explains that mouth guards help prevent tooth damage by separating your upper and lower teeth. A 2007 Cochrane review and a 2021 systematic review also found insufficient evidence that occlusal splints consistently reduce sleep bruxism.

Some research suggests that different guard materials may affect nighttime jaw-muscle activity differently, which could explain why certain people experience more discomfort.

Which Night Guard Types May Affect Teeth Grinding?

Night guards come in different materials and designs, including soft, hard, and dual-layer options.

A small 1987 study by Okeson, published in the Journal of the American Dental Association, found that soft splints increased nighttime jaw-muscle activity in some participants, while hard splints reduced activity in most. However, the study involved only 10 people, so its findings shouldn't be generalized to everyone.

The Cleveland Clinic explains the differences between common mouth guard types. Here's a quick comparison:

Guard Type Design Research Findings
Soft boil-and-bite Flexible, molded at home Not tested separately in the Okeson study
Soft custom Flexible material made from a dental impression Increased muscle activity in some participants in a small study
Hard custom Rigid material made from a dental impression Reduced muscle activity in most participants in the small study
Dual-layer Hard outer layer with a softer inner layer Not studied separately

Is a hard night guard better for heavy grinders? It may offer greater durability, but research doesn't establish that it's the best option for everyone. Your dentist can assess your tooth wear and recommend a suitable appliance.

For more information, explore our guides on acrylic vs. silicone night guards and which night guard thickness is right for you.

How to Tell If Your Night Guard Is Causing Problems

If your jaw feels worse after wearing a night guard, watch for these signs:

  • New jaw soreness: Your jaw feels tighter or more uncomfortable in the morning.
  • Bite changes: Your teeth don't come together the same way after removing your guard.
  • Tooth sensitivity: Certain teeth become newly sensitive or uncomfortable.
  • Poor fit: Your guard feels loose, shifts around, or causes uneven pressure.
  • Visible damage: You notice cracks, rough edges, or unusual wear.

What should you do if your night guard causes pain?

Stop using an appliance that causes pain and consult your dentist or doctor. Avoid adjusting a custom guard yourself.

Before your appointment:

  1. Note when your symptoms started and how they've changed.
  2. Check your guard for cracks or visible wear.
  3. Bring it to your dentist so they can assess its fit and condition.

Persistent jaw discomfort may also involve temporomandibular disorders (TMD), which require a separate evaluation.

For related concerns, read our guides on why your bite feels weird after wearing a night guard and why your front teeth hurt after wearing a night guard.

Find a Night Guard That Fits Your Teeth

A comfortable, properly fitted guard can make protecting your teeth easier. If you're considering a custom option, ClearClub's custom-fit night guard is made from an impression of your teeth that you take at home in about five minutes.

Its dual-layer design combines a hard outer layer for grinding resistance with a softer inner layer. Choose from 1.3 mm for light grinding, 2 mm (our most popular), or 3 mm for heavy grinding. ClearClub also offers one free thickness swap and a 30-day fit guarantee with a free remake or refund.


    Get Yours Today  



Frequently Asked Questions

❓ Can a night guard stop teeth grinding completely?

Not reliably. Night guards primarily protect your teeth from grinding damage rather than eliminate bruxism. Your dentist can help identify contributing factors and discuss management options.

❓ Can a night guard make clenching worse?

Possibly. Limited research suggests soft splints may increase nighttime jaw-muscle activity in some people, but this doesn't mean all soft guards cause more clenching.

❓ When should I stop wearing my night guard?

Stop using your guard if it causes pain and consult your dentist or doctor. Also seek an evaluation for persistent jaw discomfort, bite changes, or tooth damage.

Looking for something else? Check our full FAQ section.

 

Back to blog